Table 4 List of papers cross referenced from “Categorization of security pattern research” section and “IoT architecture” section
From: A decade of research on patterns and architectures for IoT security
Primary study # | Categorization of security pattern research | IoT architecture | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Perception | Network | Application | ||||||||
C1 | C2 | C3 | L1 | L2 | L3 | L4 | L5 | L6 | L7 | |
Vijayakumaran et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Vithya Vijayalakshmi and Arockiam (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||
Portal et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Karaarslan et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Perera et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||||
Dhieb et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Koo et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||
Robles Enciso et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||
Park (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||||
Koshy et al. (2020) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Attia et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Pape and Rannenberg (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||
Fysarakis et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Tiburski et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Zhang et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Karmakar et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Durresi et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Jerald et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||
Petroulakis et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Syed et al. (2018) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Witti and Konstantas (2018) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Pahl et al. (2018) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||||
Zhu and Badr (2018) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||
Schuß et al. (2018) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||||
Alphand et al. (2018) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||
Pacheco et al. (2019) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Lee and Law (2017) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||
Ye and Qian (2017) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Pacheco et al. (2018) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Ntuli and Abu-Mahfouz (2016) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Pacheco et al. (2016) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||
Lessa dos Santos et al. (2015) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||
Vučinić et al. (2015) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||
Ur-Rehman and Zivic (2015) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||
Garcia-Morchon et al. (2013) | \({\checkmark }\) | |||||||||
Goncalves et al. (2013) | \({\checkmark }\) | \({\checkmark }\) | ||||||||
Total (\({\checkmark }\)): | 16 | 30 | 21 | 28 | 31 | 11 | 5 | 4 | 21 | 3 |