Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison experiment results of BRITD and 9 baselines

From: BRITD: behavior rhythm insider threat detection with time awareness and user adaptation

Model

Scen. 1

Scen. 2

Scen. 3

Scen. 4

Scen. 5

Overall

AUC

P

AUC

P

AUC

P

AUC

P

AUC

P

AUC

P

BRITD*

0.9957

0.9333

0.8707

0.2629

1.0000

1.0000

0.9999

0.9900

0.9985

0.8500

0.9730

0.8072

HMM-BRITD

0.9152

0.4267

0.6310

0.1861

1.0000

1.0000

1.0000

1.0000

0.9049

0.0504

0.8902

0.5326

IF-6h-129\(\times \)4

0.8970

0.5129

0.5224

0.1839

0.9100

0.7333

0.9668

0.3023

0.4439

0.0152

0.7480

0.3495

OCSVM-6h-129\(\times \)4

0.9394

0.6000

0.6725

0.1758

1.0000

1.0000

0.8009

0.0763

0.4780

0.0093

0.7782

0.3723

FNN-6h-129\(\times \)4

0.9197

0.4771

0.6240

0.2074

1.0000

1.0000

0.9917

0.7020

0.9288

0.0654

0.8928

0.4904

BiLSTM-6h-129\(\times \)4

0.7000

0.2050

0.5753

0.1873

1.0000

1.0000

0.9474

0.3227

0.6180

0.0130

0.7681

0.3456

IF-24h

0.8545

0.3976

0.6737

0.2241

0.8800

0.6400

0.9999

0.9900

0.7541

0.0228

0.8325

0.4549

OCSVM-24h

0.8030

0.2308

0.6159

0.1758

0.8000

0.5000

0.9566

0.2813

0.9024

0.0476

0.8156

0.2471

FNN-24h

0.7561

0.2688

0.6384

0.1891

0.8600

0.6667

0.9983

0.9274

0.9298

0.2759

0.8365

0.4656

BiLSTM-24h

0.8942

0.3750

0.6628

0.2194

0.6998

0.4000

0.9958

0.7366

0.7026

0.0193

0.7910

0.3501

  1. *Bold indicates optimal results; star indicates our model